14 Best Rated Electric Fireplace Inserts For Existing Fireplaces 2023

• Best Overall: DIMPLEX DF3033ST 33" Electric Fireplace Insert, Model, 120V, 780W, 8.3 Amps, Black
• Best Budget: TURBRO Eternal Flame EF23-LG Electric Fireplace Logs, 23" Remote Control Fireplace Insert
• Best Value: Touchstone 80006 - Forte Recessed Mounted Electric Fireplace
• Editor's Choise: Benrocks 40'' Electric Fireplace Inserts, Recessed & Built in Wall Electric Fireplace Heater

Related post

• The 11 Best Fireplace Screen And Tools 

• Top 14 Small Electric Fireplace Inserts 

• 8 Best Rated Direct Vent Gas Fireplace

• 16 Best Rated Electric Fireplace Logs 

• 9 Best Rated Peel And Stick Tile For Fireplace

#1 PuraFlame Klaus Electric Fireplace Insert with Fire Crackling Sound

Specs:

• Brand: PuraFlame
• Dimensions: 8.78"D x 35.04"W x 26.96"H
• Material: Wood, Resin, Glass
• Finish Type: Wood
• Installation Type: Freestanding, Wall Mount
• Heat Output: 5118 British Thermal Units
• Special Feature: Flame Effect, Adjustable Thermostat
• Style: Antique
• Color: Grey, clear
• Ventilation Type: Vent Free

What we like:

• Realistic flame effect: The PuraFlame Klaus Electric Fireplace Insert features three flame settings with variable intensity and luminosity that can be used with or without heat, making it suitable for use throughout the year.
• With 100% energy-saving LED technology, this fireplace insert provides the cozy ambience of a conventional fireplace without the associated high energy costs.
• With its three-sided interior brick wall, glass entrance, and mesh screen, the PuraFlame Klaus Electric Fireplace Insert is a stylish addition to any interior design.
• The insert can be installed without the assistance of a professional because of its flat base.

What we don't like:

• This fireplace insert has a limited heating capacity and cannot serve as a room's principal source of heat. It can only heat up to 400 square feet.

Our Verdict:

• Overall, the PuraFlame Klaus Electric Fireplace Insert is a fantastic upgrade for any residence with an existing fireplace. It provides the coziness of a traditional fireplace without the burden and mess of a wood-burning fireplace, thanks to its realistic flame effect, energy efficiency, and antique design. Its heating capacity is limited to supplementary heat for up to 400 square feet, but it is simple to install and a stylish and functional addition to any home's décor.
   

#2 Touchstone 80006 - Forte Recessed Mounted Electric Fireplace 

Specs:

• The Touchstone 80006 Forte Recessed-Mounted Electric Fireplace is a fashionable and contemporary alternative to conventional fireplaces. Its dimensions of 5 inches in depth, 39.25 inches in width, and 28 inches in height make it suitable for a variety of living environments. The fireplace has a glass front and is finished in elegant black. It provides a heating area of 400 square feet and a heat discharge of 5100 BTUs. The Forte features five flame settings ranging from a soft ember light to a raging fire. It features a genuine three-color flame and the option to use either faux logs or crystals.

What we like:

• The Forte is a versatile and functional electric fireplace that provides householders with a number of advantages. Its recessive design makes it ideal for contemporary homes with sleek, minimalist décor. The fireplace's realistic flames and appearance of a real fire create a comfortable and warm environment in any room. We like that it comes with an IR remote that allows you to control the flame hue and intensity, as well as the heater and timer. This electric fireplace is also ventless, allowing for simple installation without the need for gas lines or venting.

What we don't like:

• Despite the Forte's many advantages, there are a few disadvantages to consider. First, it may not be suitable as a primary heat source because its utmost heat output is 5100 BTUs. The Forte can only be installed in a wall recess, which may limit its placement options in some residences. Lastly, some householders may find the recommended 8-inch distance between the fireplace and television inconvenient.

Our Verdict:

• The Touchstone 80006 Forte Recessed Mounted Electric Fireplace is an outstanding addition to any household. It is a practical option for many homeowners due to its versatility and convenience of installation, as well as its stylish appearance and realistic flames. It may not be suitable as a primary heat source, but it can provide sufficient warmth to warm up a room or cellar. We suggest the Forte to anyone seeking a contemporary and functional electric fireplace.
   

#3 LegendFlame 23" W Free Standing Electric Fireplace Log Set

Specs:

• Dimensions: 9.5"D x 23"W x 20"H
• Material: Metal
• Finish Type: Powder Coated
• Installation Type: Freestanding
• Heat Output: 5000 British Thermal Units
• Special Features: Flame Effect, Adjustable Flame
• Style: Nora
• Color: Black
• Ventilation Type: Vent Free

What we like:

• The LegendFlame 23" W Freestanding Electric Fireplace Log Set is an excellent choice for those who desire the appearance of a wood-burning fireplace without the inconvenience of dealing with smoke and dust. We especially value the realistic and genuine resin logs with ember bed, which emit a breathtaking flame effect. The adjustable flame feature enables us to modify the size and brightness of the flame to suit our preferences. The 100% energy-efficient LED is also a wonderful feature because it can be used year-round without worrying about high energy costs. The remote makes it simple to operate and modify the settings from a distance.

What we don't like:

• The electric fireplace log set's heat output is adequate for rooms up to 400 square feet, which is insufficient for larger rooms or open-plan living spaces. In addition, it is not designed to be a primary heat source and cannot replace a central heating system. The crackling fire sound could have been more authentic.

Our Verdict:

• Overall, the LegendFlame 23" W Free Standing Electric Fireplace Log Set is an excellent addition to any space that requires a touch of warmth and ambience. This product's eye-catching flame effect and adjustable flame feature are among its highlights. Even though it is not the primary source of heat, it is sufficient for heating small to medium-sized rooms. The remote control is an added convenience that makes adjusting the parameters without leaving your seat simple. Despite a few minor flaws, we enthusiastically recommend this electric fireplace log set to anyone seeking a cost-effective and hassle-free way to experience the warmth and ambiance of a wood-burning fireplace.

#4 Benrocks 40'' Electric Fireplace Inserts, Recessed & Built in Wall Electric Fireplace Heater 

Specs:

• Brand: Benrocks
• Product Dimensions: 8.84"D x 40"W x 27.32"H
• Material: Tempered Glass, Metal
• Finish Type: Tempered Glass
• Installation Type: Built In, Wall Mount
• Heat Output: 5100 British Thermal Units
• Style: Insert
• Color: Black
• Ventilation Type: Vent Free
• Heating Coverage: 5 square feet

What we like:

• The Benrocks 40" Electric Fireplace Inserts feature a streamlined and contemporary design that complements any interior design. It is simple to implement and can be recessed or wall-mounted. The fireplace is endowed with energy-saving LED technology that produces a realistic flame effect with variable brightness, flame speed, and color options.
• In addition, the fireplace includes a wireless remote control and a touch screen, making it simple to operate from the comfort of your sofa. The built-in speaker system generates the sound of smoldering wood, enhancing the realism of the experience.
• Benrocks electric fireplace inserts prioritize safety with an overheating protection system that automatically shuts off the heater in the event of a problem.

What we don't like:

• The fireplace's heating capacity is limited to 5 cubic feet, which may not be sufficient for larger rooms. In addition, the price may be a touch higher than other available options.

Our Verdict:

• The Benrocks 40" Electric Fireplace Inserts offer an excellent blend of design, functionality, and security. The customizable features and realistic flame effects make it a wonderful addition to any room, and the integrated safety system allows you to enjoy the warmth without worry. It may be a touch more expensive than other alternatives, but its quality and durability make it a worthwhile investment.

#5 PuraFlame Western Electric Fireplace Insert with Fire Crackling Sound

Specs:

• Brand: PuraFlame
• Dimensions: 35 3/24" x 22 7/16" x 8 25/32"
• Material: Metal
• Finish Type: Wood
• Installation Type: Wall Mount, Freestanding
• Heat Output: 5100 BTUs
• Style: Western
• Color: Black
• Ventilation Type: Vent Free
• Heating Coverage: 400 sq. ft.

What we like:

• The PuraFlame Western Electric Fireplace Insert offers an excellent combination of features, design, and practicality. The LED technology provides a realistic flame effect with three configurations that can be used with or without heat, making it a year-round option. The three-sided interior brick wall and clean glass front trim design add to the fireplace's overall appeal, and the lifelike resin log resting on the grate above the ember bed gives it the appearance of a wood-burning fireplace. The adjustable thermostat and remote control make the temperature and flame settings simple to operate and adjust. The design of the flat bottom makes installation simple, and the one-year warranty provides peace of mind.

What we don't like:

• Even though the PuraFlame Western Electric Fireplace Insert produces a substantial quantity of heat, it is not suitable as a primary heat source and can only provide supplemental heat for up to 400 square feet. As installation necessitates a flat surface, some users may find the installation process to be somewhat difficult.

Our Verdict:

• Overall, the PuraFlame Western Electric Fireplace Insert is an excellent option for those in search of an electric fireplace with a realistic flame effect, temperature adjustment, and user-friendly remote control. It is ideal for small to medium-sized rooms and provides an excellent alternative to traditional wood-burning fireplaces without the inconvenience of dust and ash cleanup. It may not be suitable as a primary heat source, but it is an excellent supplementary heat source that enhances the ambiance of any room. Additionally, the one-year warranty and customer service support provide users with peace of mind.
   

• Measure the existing fireplace's dimensions to ensure that the insert will fit precisely.
• Consider the extent of the space you wish to heat and select an insert with the corresponding heat output.
• Choose an insert that complements your home's aesthetic.
• Look for an insert with realistic flame effects to achieve a genuine fireplace experience.
• Determine your budget and select an insert within that range.
   

Can an electric fireplace insert be installed in a masonry fireplace?

Yes, an electric fireplace insert can be installed in a masonry fireplace if the insert's dimensions match those of the fireplace.

Do electric fireplace components require ventilation?

No, electric fireplace inserts do not require ventilation because, unlike wood-burning fireplaces, they do not produce detrimental emissions.

Can I use an electric fireplace insert as my home's primary heat source?

Although electric fireplace inserts can provide heat, they are not intended to be your primary source of heat. They are intended as a supplement to your current heating system.

Are inserts for electric fireplaces energy-efficient?

Yes, electric fireplace inserts are energy-efficient, as they consume less electricity than conventional heating methods.

How do I sanitize the insert of my electric fireplace?

The majority of electric fireplace inserts can be cleaned with a gentle soap and a delicate cloth. Unplug the device before cleansing it.
 

Electric fireplace inserts are an excellent alternative to traditional wood-burning fireplaces for upgrading an existing fireplace. Consider the insert's size, heat output, design, flame effects, and cost before making a purchase. You will be able to discover the best electric fireplace insert for your home if you follow these tips and consider our top recommendations.