Kirby Research is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more

Top 12 Colored Eyeliners of March 2023

There are a ton of factors to consider when making the decision to buy colored eyeliners. Some people feel that they make the eyes look bigger, others think they make them less attractive. Some people find them difficult to use and others find them very easy to apply. Ultimately, the decision comes down to what you think looks best on you.

Top Picks

Best Overall:BONNIE CHOICE Colored Eyeliner Pencils Set 
(The BONNIE CHOICE Colored Eyeliner Pens Set 20 Colors Matte Eye Liner Pencils Colorful Eyeliner Set comes with an all-new retractable pencil that is long lasting and waterproof. It also has a variety of colors to choose from, making it a great gift for women who love to experiment with makeup. Plus, the eyedropper-style pen makes it easy to apply color without having to worry about fumble around in your brush bin.)

Best Budget:KARNAR 6Pcs Deep Sea Blue Green Colored 
(The KARNAR 6Pcs Deep Sea Blue Green Colored Shimmer Glitter Eye Liner Shadow Pencil Pen Set is perfect for drawing attention to your eyes. The shimmers of deep blue and green added an intense effect to any outfit, and will make you look more striking than ever. With six pens in each color, you have plenty of options for making any statement.)

Editor's Choise:COOSA Waterproof Eye Liner Pencil Set 
(The COOSA Waterproof Eye Liner Pencil Set 20 Colors Natural Matte Long Lasting Eyeliners Eye Makeup Pencils are easy apply colored eyeliner retractable eye makeup pencils and shadow pens. They come in a stylish black hardshell case. The pencils are non-toxic, and have a long lasting ink. With its natural matte finish, theseEyeliners will give you the perfect look for any outfit.)

Related post

Comparison Table

Showing  11 - 12  in  12 results
    AI Score

    Reviews are based on big data aggregated from sales pages and product buyer reviews. All ranking arrangements are automatically AI-driven according to product buyer reviews.

  • Brand
    AI Score

    Reviews are based on big data aggregated from sales pages and product buyer reviews. All ranking arrangements are automatically AI-driven according to product buyer reviews.

  • Brand

Last update on 2023-03-31 / Affiliate links / Images, Product Titles, and Product Highlights from Amazon Product Advertising API

3 ratings


What color eyeliner is best?

The best eyeliner is the one that will make your eyes look their best. You can find different colors of eyeliner to suit your own style and personality.

Which color eyeliner is best for fair skin?

The best eyeliner for fair skin is usually brown, grey or green.

What color eyeliner for natural look?

Brown eyeliner is the most natural looking eyeliner. It's easy to use and gives a subtle look.

Is colored eyeliner in style?

There is no one definitive answer to this question; each individual's taste in eyeliner will vary. However, some people might prefer brightly-colored eyeliner over traditional black or brown eyeliner because it gives their eyes a more vibrant appearance.

Should eyeliner match your eye color?

There is no one-size-fits-all answer to this question. However, if you want to achieve a more blended eye look, it's important to choose eyeliner that matches your eye color. For example, black or brown eyeliner will help to contrast your eyes and give them a more intense look.


There are many reasons why someone might want to purchase colored eyeliners. Some people enjoy the artistic look of eyes with different colors, while others may just need a new set of eyeshadow c. However, there are a few important things to keep in mind when purchasing these products. For example, it is important to make sure that the colors you are choosing are actually compatible with your own personal skin tone.

Lumia Shaffer
Lumia Shaffer

I'm Lumia Shaffer! I'm a Kirby Research author, with a passion for writing, I've researched and published many in-depth product research articles!
My Twitter: